98: Jamie Mills , RDN, CD-N (aka “The Sleeved Dietitian”) on Breaking Plateaus and Maximizing Nutrition After Bariatric Surgery

Subscribe on Apple 

Subscribe on Spotify 

Despite what anyone says, bariatric surgery is NOT the easy way out. Much like GLP-1 medications, it’s just a tool—one piece of a much larger puzzle. To truly succeed, we need other tools in our toolbelt to navigate the challenges: restriction, food guilt, fear of failure, and the overwhelming uncertainty of what to eat after weight loss surgery.

The good news is, you don’t have to figure it all out on your own. With the right education, resources, support, and genuine connections, you can create the post-op life you’ve always dreamed of—a life that’s fulfilling, sustainable, and healthy.

In this post, we’ll dive into some of the biggest challenges bariatric patients face after surgery and share actionable strategies to overcome them, inspired by insights from Jamie Mills, RDN, CDN, aka The Sleeved Dietitian. From practical protein hacks for busy days to shifting your mindset around plateaus (hint: sometimes adding more is the answer!), this guide will empower you to make lasting changes. Plus, we’ll touch on why you’re not meant to stick to a restrictive post-op diet forever—and how to embrace a balanced approach for long-term success.

Nutritional Challenges After Bariatric Surgery

After bariatric surgery, the journey doesn’t end once the procedure is complete. In fact, it’s just the beginning of a lifelong process of understanding your body's evolving needs and building sustainable habits. Let’s explore some of the top nutritional challenges bariatric patients face post-surgery—and practical strategies to overcome them.

1. Getting Enough Protein

Protein is the foundation of a bariatric patient’s diet, not because you require more than the average person, but because your stomach’s reduced size makes every bite count. Without sufficient protein, you risk protein-calorie malnutrition, muscle loss, and impaired metabolic health.

However, meeting your protein goals can be tough:

• Certain protein-rich foods may no longer sit well post-surgery.
• Changes in taste and texture preferences can make old favorites less appealing.
• The volume of food you can handle is initially very small, leaving little room for variety.

Pro Tip: Focus on high-protein options that are easier to digest, such as Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, protein shakes, or soft-cooked eggs. Experiment with different options to find what works for your new palate and digestion.

2. Overcoming the Fear of Eating More

One of the most common misconceptions is that post-surgery, you’re supposed to eat tiny portions forever. While your initial intake might be as little as 2-6 ounces per meal, your stomach is designed to regain some elasticity as you heal. This natural process allows you to eat more over time without compromising your surgery’s success.

Despite this, many patients experience fear and guilt as they notice their portions increasing:

• Worrying they’re “stretching their stomach” or undoing their surgery.
• Comparing themselves to others on social media who may claim they stay full after just a few bites.
• Feeling pressured to adhere to a rigid post-op diet indefinitely.

Mindset Shift: Eating slightly larger portions is not a failure—it’s part of the process. Your stomach is a muscle, and as it adapts, you should too. Focus on nutrient density and balance rather than strictly limiting volume.

3. Breaking Free from Long-Term Restriction

The initial post-op diet is intentionally restrictive, often limited to protein and low-carb vegetables, to support healing and weight loss. But this phase is not meant to last forever. Staying overly restrictive long-term can lead to:

• Nutritional deficiencies.
• Bingeing or nighttime snacking due to unmet cravings.
• A disordered relationship with food.

Balanced Approach: Over time, reintroduce a variety of foods while maintaining protein as a priority. Incorporate whole grains, fruits, and healthy fats into your diet gradually. 

4. Navigating the Lack of Long-Term Support

One of the biggest hurdles many bariatric patients face is the absence of guidance once the initial post-op period ends. Many surgery centers emphasize a strict diet without providing tools to transition into a sustainable, balanced lifestyle.

If you’re struggling to move beyond the early diet phase:

• Seek support from bariatric-specialized dietitians or coaches like Jamie Mills, who advocate for a more balanced and empowering approach.
• Focus on your long-term goals, such as maintaining weight loss and enjoying a diverse, satisfying diet, rather than clinging to outdated, overly restrictive plans.

5. Adapting to a Changing Body

Your nutritional needs will continue to evolve over time. Factors such as age, hormonal changes (e.g., menopause), and activity levels will influence what your body needs to thrive.

Key Takeaway: Nutrition after bariatric surgery isn’t about finding one “perfect” way to eat and sticking to it forever. Instead, it’s about learning to adapt, listen to your body, and balance structure with flexibility.

By addressing these challenges head-on and embracing a mindset of growth and adaptation, you can build a post-surgery lifestyle that’s both sustainable and fulfilling. Remember, you’re not in this alone—resources, experts, and a supportive community can help guide your journey to long-term success.

Practical Protein Strategies for Bariatric and GLP-1 Patients

It can be challenging for bariatric and GLP-1 patients to meet their protein needs, especially when volume is limited. Here’s a breakdown of practical strategies and top protein suggestions:

1. Use High-Quality Protein Sources

Focus on lean protein options with high biological value, such as:

• Animal-based proteins: Chicken, turkey, lean beef, fish, and eggs provide all essential amino acids.
• Soy-based proteins: For vegetarians or those seeking plant-based options, tofu, tempeh, and edamame are excellent alternatives.

2. Rely on Supplements When Needed

• Protein shakes and bars can be helpful during early post-surgery stages or while adjusting to GLP-1 medications.
• However, avoid over-relying on them. They’re a tool to bridge the gap, not a long-term replacement for meals. Many patients fall into the habit of meeting their protein goals with supplements but neglect building high-protein meals or snacks.

3. Make Protein Convenient

Busy schedules demand easy, quick options:

• Rotisserie chicken: Pre-shredded and ready to pair with sauces like sugar-free barbecue for flavor.
• Low-carb chicken nuggets or tenders: Brands like Simply Bare offer nutrient-dense, quick options that are air-fryer ready.
• Deli meat and cheese roll-ups: Portable and high-protein for on-the-go snacks.
• Meat sticks and yogurt: Simple grab-and-go options that are easy to fit into your routine.

4. Adopt the "Good Enough is Good Enough" Mindset

There’s no need to overcomplicate meal prep. Stick to protein foods you enjoy and are easy to prepare. This is especially critical for those juggling busy lives or adapting to post-op or GLP-1 eating habits.

5. Transition to a Balanced Plate Method

As you progress, it's crucial to shift from relying on supplements to incorporating whole food-based meals. A simple plate method can help—start with protein as the base, then add vegetables and healthy fats. This approach keeps your meals balanced and aligned with your nutritional goals.

The key is to make this process easy and enjoyable. By focusing on convenience and tasty options, you can stick to your protein goals and build habits that last long-term.